Will You Get Better Results From AM or PM Lifting?
Weight training is key to a bodybuilders success, so it is understandable why they would only want 100% out of their workouts. In order to move the most weight, you have to be at your best, both physically and mentally. But when are you at your best?
What is the best time of day to weight train? Why? Would alternating your workouts from morning to afternoon to night have any positive or negative effects?
People train when it’s convenient or when they feel like it, letting their life or emotions dictate when they hit the gym. However, changes in measures of muscular performance as well as hormone levels fluctuate throughout the day. Is it possible to choose a specific time where you have peak performance and hormone levels? Let’s break down the science.
The Regulator of Life: Circadian Rhythms
A circadian rhythm is a 24-hour cycle controlling all the physiological processes of humans and animals. The functions of the circadian clock include organisation of sleep/wake patterns, control of your hormones and metabolism, and even athletic performance.
Related article: Build Muscle Or Lose Fat First to Maximise Muscle Gains
The circadian system becomes responsive and adapts to environmental changes such as light/dark cycles, food intake, and exercise. The most relevant aspects for optimal training time are its effects on regulation of nervous system activity and hormonal production. By understanding these processes you may have a better idea of when to train and how the time of day may affect your results.
Both of these fluctuate throughout the day, peaking at certain times while being low at others. Here’s a depiction of the typical fluctuations of biochemical and physiological events with a 24-hour period, known as a biorhythm:
As you can see, fluctuations throughout the day may have an impact on our performance levels and influence the hormonal concentrations around training. Although some data suggests that training in the early evening may provide the greatest force and muscle strength, it’s not always as black and white as that.
Related article: 9 Fabulous Foods to Help You Sleep Better And Feel Revitalised
Have you ever wondered why most sporting events are played in the afternoon, and why most world records are set in the mid-afternoon to evening? Studies in a variety of sports and activities – weightlifting, cycling, etc. – have shown measures of strength and power to be highest in the afternoon/evening compared to the morning.
So, if you’re an elite athlete trying to win a competition or set some records, this time of day may help.
Optimal body temperature for training normally occurs during this time, providing you optimal nerve conduction velocity, joint mobility and safety, metabolism, and muscular blood flow. Your core body temp is low at night, rises quickly upon awakening, and reaches a maximum in the evening.
Keep in mind that activities requiring strength and power have been shown to be more affected by time of day than other forms of activities, such as endurance events.
Related article: How Much Can You Lift – How To Calculate Your One-Rep Max (1RM)?
The circadian rhythm also affects the fluctuations of your key hormones. The most important hormones related to training and body composition are testosterone, cortisol, and growth hormone. Testosterone is well known as a potent anabolic, muscle-building hormone. If we look at our testosterone levels throughout the day, in most cases, they’re highest in the morning and will drop throughout the day.
However, this normal rhythm can be altered depending on your lifestyle, sleep, and daily activity. One important consideration is that testosterone levels normally increase after exercise, and the rise in testosterone after exercise appears to be more profound in the evening than it is in the morning.
Growth hormone (GH) is another muscle building hormone. Normally, the majority of GH is released in “pulses” when you sleep, with the largest pulses occurring before midnight and some smaller pulses in the early morning. As with testosterone, intense exercise acutely elevates growth hormone levels, providing spikes post-workout and altering our body’s normal pattern at night.
In contrast, cortisol is a stress hormone with a bad reputation as it can cause muscle protein breakdown. While this is sometimes overplayed, cortisol does have some important roles. If cortisol is left elevated for some time it may have detrimental effects.
Our cortisol levels at rest follow a natural pattern, peaking in the morning and decreasing during the evening. The elevations of cortisol in response to exercise are lower in the early evening compared with the morning. In other words, if cortisol or other related factors such as recovery are an issue and you want to keep them under control, training in the morning may be best.
Related article: 8 Ways To Increase Testosterone Levels Naturally
Lifestyle and Preference
Your preference is always an unappreciated yet vitally important aspect of diet or training. Far too often, people will make programming decisions based on what they believe to be “most optimal” at the cost of their own preference and lifestyle. For example, if training in the morning suits you better, is it best to disregard this and train in the evening for some form of hormonal and strength benefit?
The answer is no. Thinking logically, even if you were to get a 5% improvement in the evening, this would easily be countered by the fact you’re probably less motivated and tired after work. You may also have less energy and will have decreased performance, which probably leads to you doing less total volume. Hey, you want to get home, right?
These variables, particularly intensity and volume (total sets, reps, and weight lifted), are proven to be the most important aspects of training for muscle growth. To maximise your progress, pick your training time on these two key variables. Train when you can perform best and have an uninterrupted workout and plenty of time for volume.
Related article: The Benefits Of Chicken For Extreme Training And Growth
You can see the same issues with dieting. For example, a complex strategy, which may increase fat loss by 5%, will often be very difficult to sustain. The plan will be much harder to stick to, be less enjoyable, and cause you to quit or be less consistent. Consistency is the number one factor, so reducing your chances of achieving this for a small boost is a recipe for disaster, whether it’s training or diet.
Pros vs. Average Joes
If you’re a pro athlete who trains and competes for a career, training in the PM could give you that 1-2% boost that makes the difference between winning a race and placing tenth. However, a lot more research is needed to draw solid conclusions.
For most people, the optimal time to train is when it best suits your lifestyle and when you know you can go into the gym with focus, motivation, and energy. This is in the morning before work when your mind is clear and you can give 100% to your workout. With others, it may be in the PM. It simply depends on your own preferences.
Ask yourself if it’s really that important when you may end up leaving early, losing intensity and focus or, worst of all, not being consistent. Remember, consistency trumps “optimal” when it comes to training and nutrition.